Compare and contrast the movie speak to the book speak. The assault is depicted in a closeup of the anguished face of the attacked high school girl. The book s synopsis is the real issue here as is the movie rating which seem to make this young adult novel into a tale fit for young adults. It has become a book that all families can use to talk to their kids about harsh realities of life, and the legal and moral rules that govern consent and sexual intimacy. The book goes into more detail about here apperance and makes here seem more far gone than in the movie. Rent speak 2004 starring kristen stewart and hallee hirsh on dvd and bluray. Speak study guide contains a biography of laurie halse anderson, literature essays, quiz questions, major themes, characters, and a full. Why are books always better than the movie versions. August before her freshman year, melinda and her closest friends attend a party with seniors and beer. Her parents and guidance counselor try to get her to open up about her poor academic performance, but melinda refuses to speak to them. Steven spielberg finally a book that celebrates the processthe dynamic web of people, technique, and artistryunderneath every foot of celluloid. Speak by laurie halse anderson goodreads share book. Speak by laurie halse anderson is multiple awardwinning books, but it is also listed by the american library association as one of the top 100 books challenged between 20002009.
Speak study guide contains a biography of laurie halse anderson, literature essays, quiz questions, major themes, characters, and a full summary and analysis. Like many novels with high school settings, speak is deeply focused on ideas of growing up and coming of age. The movie version of speak was very different from the book. Kristen stewart is a teenager traumatized into silence after a summer party ends in a police raid that leaves her ostracized by her. Melinda sordino, the star of speak, goes through intense growth over the course of the story. It stars kristen stewart as melinda sordino, a high school freshman who practically stops talking after a senior student rapes her. Freeman about what had happened during the school year and what had caused it, but at the end of the movie. Maya angelou was also raped, and didnt speak afterwards. I looked at five ow these are in no particular order being that i changed some after i finished watching the movie.
I am suppose to choose and read a book for high school next year and i was wondering if speak was a good book and i also have to take a test on it. In laurie halse andersons powerful novel, an utterly believable heroine with a bitterly ironic voice delivers a blow to the hypocritical world of high school. Book summary over the summer, she and her friends went to a party and melinda ended up calling the police, causing her friends and everyone at the party to socially reject her. Kristein is fabulous in the movie, at this much age she performed too good. What makes this book s exploration of that subject particularly poignant and pointed, however, is that melinda has. Melindas only friend is heather, a new student, who tries to get melinda involved in. Movie speak wont guarantee you a job, but having a knowledge of the. In the movie, melinda never hangs up the poster of maya angelou in her closet, like she does in the book. Speak is a 2004 american independent comingofage teen drama film based on the awardwinning 1999 novel of the same name by laurie halse anderson. In 2004, jessica sharzer directed the film adaptation, starring kristen stewart as melinda.
The poster represents how melinda was unable to speak about her rape and how trapped she was. I think most of the victims are not as courageous like melinda, who is able to stand up and speak about the rape event. In the book, the school changed the mascot from trojans to devils to tigers then the hornets. Speak tells the story of melinda sordino, a ninth grader at merryweather high school in syracuse, new york. Speak, published in 1999, is a young adult novel by laurie halse anderson that tells the story. Your book s opening hook has to be stronger than a movie s. Speak is a movie about a 14 years old girl which was raped by his senior in a party and after that incident she does not speak much. When writing a book, is it okay to mentionmake references. Between the book and movie speak, there are many differences between the two. There are a lot of similarities and differences between the book and the movie. What are the similarities between the book and the movie. After reading the book speak by laure halse anderson and then watching the movie speak, i see that there are many differences between the book and the movie.
Anyone with a story to tell can write a book, either for their own enjoyment or to publish for all to see. One difference is that in the movie, melinda meets heather on the bus. In the movie she does have the dark baggy clothes but there is scars from biting on here lips and theres no scabs or anything like that. Differences between the movie speak and the book speak. This book will be disturbing to many young adults and to many full adults. But that said, this book might be even better for those of us who do not work in the movies and just like them, because movie speak will make watching movies.
This book is a great reference for someone breaking into the movies and, because one probably cant memorize the full plate of strange terms in a single reading, good to keep around so that when you are on a set, you can do a quick look up. Every year several books are challenged and banned across the nation by individuals and organizations who believe the content of the books is inappropriate. Comingofage novels are often novels of education and like speak they often not always. Speak video viewing guide loudoun county public schools. Getting started is often the hardest part, so set up a good workspace, create a regular writing schedule, and. In the book speak, by laurie halse anderson, melinda sordino is forced into the worst. Speak questions and answers discover the community of teachers, mentors and students just like you that can answer any question you might have on speak. Speak is what fancy literary types call a bildungsroman. In the movie, there is much less narration, and you hear melindas thoughts less than you do in the book. After accidentally busting an end of summer party due to an unnamed incident, melinda is ostracized by her. Some of these differences affect the meaning of the movie. Are the book and the movie speak basically the same. It helped me break the twentyfive years of silence id maintained after my sexual assault.
Kristeins eyes speak too much in spite of she dont speak much. Speak themes from litcharts the creators of sparknotes. Parents need to know that speak, a showtime 2004 movie based on a novel of the same name by laurie halse anderson, is an intense study of the aftermath of a sexual assault by a high school boy at a party where there was underage drinking. Litcharts assigns a color and icon to each theme in speak, which you can use to track the themes throughout the work. Sweeney and steve zahn costar in this drama based on the awardwinning novel by laurie halse anderson. Speak up for yourselfwe want to know what you have to say. Speak as a movie and book is a wellillustrated movie on sexual assault and the aftermath effect on a high school girl. They all think shes a squealer because she called the cops. In the movie, the school changed the mascot from trojans to hornets then the falcons. As the narrative progresses, melindas attempts to draw a tree come to symbolize her ability to move read full symbol analysis birds appear multiple times in the text of speak the most memorable of these appearances, of course, being. Every industry has its own lingo and the film industry has quite the colorful and historic one.
The movie speak was different then the novel in five ways. A lesson worth reading and worth analyzing every little detail, no matter how the writing is and no matter how repetitive it can get. If you like speak you might like similar movies thirteen, in the land of women, white oleander, daydream nation, teenage dirtbag. I think this is a good movie to illustrate what a girl is being through after a date rape. All in all, a great read, a fine reference and a cool little gem. Theyre not going to get up and leave the theater unless the movie really stinks halfway in. Speak was a 1999 national book award finalist for young peoples literature. Speak, to me, is taken more as a lesson than just a book. Near the beginning of the novel, melinda is assigned a tree as her yearlong assignment in art class.
In the book speak, by laurie halse anderson, melinda sordino is forced into the worst year of her life. I wrote speak when my oldest daughter went to middle school. Movie speak is from the kind of guy whod be rooting for you if you were in the film business. By the time viewers sit down to watch a movie, theyve more or less committed to the story. Steven spielberg finally a book that celebrates the processthe dynamic web of. A producer is the person who picks a story, arranges for finances, sets the budget, recruits a director, and supervises the total production of the film. Here youll find vocabulary you can use to talk bout your favourite books or films in part 1, part 2 and part 3 of the ielts speaking exam. Parents with teen children will find this movie helpful to fully understand what it feels like for a girl to suffer pains, anger, depression, and trauma associated with rape and other sexual violence against the girl child.
It is publishing the book that can triggering infringement, libel, and other legal issues. This could be for a number of reasons, be it the directors intreperetation or simpily cutting for time. What are the similarities between the book and the movie speak. Speak is an absolutely touching story about a girl who has been hurt but is unable to talk to people about it. Speak symbols from litcharts the creators of sparknotes. Differences between the movie and book speak answers. Books and movies are perhaps nowhere more different than in their opening scenes. When you are writing a book, during the actual writing process itself, yes all of these are allowed. She speaks for many a disenfranchised teenager while demonstrating the importance of speaking up for oneself.
Movie speak wont guarantee you a job, but having a knowledge of the industry terms will fool everyone into thinking you own the place. Another difference is in the movie, rachel is the person that slaps melinda when she catches her on the phone. This is important, because the poster is very symbolic towards melinda. Lena difference number one one of the biggest differences i noticed was that at the end of the book melinda tells mr. Speak, published in 1999, is a young adult novel by laurie halse anderson that tells the story of high school freshman melinda sordino.
Awardwinning short filmmaker jessica sharzer makes her feature debut with the teen drama speak, based on the youngadult novel by laurie halse anderson. Which scene of the book do you think will be the most challenging for the director of the movie. Melinda sordinos freshman year of high school is not starting off the way she wanted. One of the differences in the movie was when heather met melinda. At the party, melinda feels uncomfortable and out of place. Parents need to know that speak, a showtime 2004 movie based on a novel of the same name by laurie halse anderson, is an intense study. Books offer the reader the opportunity to interpret, imagine, and get more of the story than the movie version. This book is a great reference for someone breaking into the movies and, because one probably cant memorize the full plate of strange terms in a single reading, good to keep around so that when you are on a set. This simply constructed movie has a powerful storyline that had me drawn in from the first five minutes. I also love the fact that there is no hollywood trim on this movie, it is just a story and thats what makes it so good.